Medical tourism

Should Pakistani nationals be allowed to come to India for treatment ?

It is not only the overlooking of our humanitarian responsibility, but refusal to Pakistani nationals to receive treatment in India also causes economic loss to us.

There were many media reports that the government has significantly reduced the number of the visas issued to Pakistani nationals coming to India to seek medical treatment. If we keep in mind the strained relations between India and Pakistan and the prevailing security scenario in the country, this decision is very much, reasonable. When it comes to issuing of national security, of course, we can set aside our humanitarian duty for the Pakistani nationals.

Another equally relevant question is what do those Pakistani patients do which do not get an Indian visa. And what about those who get it for one visit but is delayed or refused for subsequent visits? Understandably, they must not be accepting it as their destiny and must be exploring other countries as alternatives.  Now we come to the main issue. What are these alternatives? In an article by Bart Van den Mooter on health tourism in Asia, the author paints the real scenario “Foreign patients are a major revenue generator for private hospitals in the region. Their share represents 40-55 percent of the private hospitals’ revenue in countries such as Singapore, Malaysia and especially Thailand. In India, medical tourism accounts for 25 percent of income, and in the Philippines, South Korea, and Taiwan, it accounts for 10-15 percent of revenue.”

One does not need a Ph.D. in economics to figure out what will happen to the share of patients going to countries like Singapore and Malaysia if we keep refusing visa to those who want to come.

So next time a Pakistani comes to for with a visa application for medical treatment in India, we can either refuse him for security reasons or approve with a smile for economic reasons. Either of the ways, somewhere he will get the treatment for sure.

2 thoughts on “Should Pakistani nationals be allowed to come to India for treatment ?

  1. Medical tourism is generally based on the local hospital/doctor recommending to the foreign one, sometimes directly by the patient too. Either way, the files are fully studied to study the legitimacy of the illness and treatment, and hence the “purpose of visit” as per visa norms. So if one looks at it as a business option, then yes the should be allowed. The only reason to stop is political bickering over letting a ill human continue to suffer. Forget business and politics, even one of the basic Hindu Dharma is the Dharma to serve humanity, and healthcare is definitely serving humanity. Sourajit Aiyer, South Asia Fast Track

    1. Thanks for reply. Good that you draw my attention to the fact that Dharma could also be the basis for healthcare related decisions. I had always nurtured the idea that it is to be use in politics only.